Allegation · work computer · browsing, messages, files, hours · a fair investigation · Acas and the ICO · facts for the panel · £800 + VAT
Misconduct and disciplinary investigations. A disciplinary panel does not need an expert witness. It needs to know what the computer shows, from someone with no stake in the outcome.
Most workplace computer allegations never go near a court. They are decided by a manager or panel following the employer's procedure, with a possible tribunal claim in the background. What that process needs is a reliable account of the facts, gathered fairly and at a cost in proportion to the issue. A factual forensic report does that job: it records what was browsed, opened, sent or deleted on the work computer, when, and under which account, and it is written by someone outside the organisation. The employer's own IT staff looking first is the commonest way such evidence is damaged, and the commonest ground on which it is later attacked.
This page quotes rules, guidance and decided cases and gives the source for each. It is not legal advice; for your own position, ask a solicitor.
Tell us the dispute and whose computer it is; you hear whether a factual report fits before any fee is taken
0800 6890668
What a factual report can give.
What is alleged, and what the computer may record.
| What is alleged | What the computer may record | What it cannot show | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prohibited websites visited at work | History, downloads, cached items, times | Private-mode browsing, in most cases | Network logs may fill gaps |
| Hours claimed but not worked | Logon, lock and activity times | Work done away from the computer | Compare with timesheets carefully |
| Harassing messages to a colleague | Messages in desktop chat and mail clients | Messages on phones | Phones are not examined here |
| Looking at records without reason | Files and applications opened | Queries inside a remote system | The system's own audit log is primary |
| 'Someone else used my login' | Whether activity fits the account's usual pattern; concurrent sessions | Who was physically present | Door logs and rotas help |
| Evidence removed once suspended | Deletion and cleaning tools, remote logins after suspension | Overwritten content | Disable remote access at suspension |
What to do first, in order.
- Secure the computer at the point of suspension or allegationCollect it, power it off, record who took it and when.
- Keep IT's hands off the contentsSuspend the account; do not let anyone log in as the user or run searches.
- Check your policiesWhat staff were told about monitoring and acceptable use. The ICO's guidance turns on transparency and proportionality.
- Define the allegation and the periodThe narrower the question, the more useful the answer and the less intrusive the examination.
- Instruct the examination and share the report fairlyAcas's guidance covers giving the employee the evidence relied on.
Do not
- Do not have a colleague or line manager search the computer.
- Do not log in with the employee's password.
- Do not widen the search to their whole personal life.
- Do not present a forensic report as proving who was at the keyboard.
- Do not skip the employee's chance to respond to it.
In more detail.
Why independence matters
An internal investigation is judged, if challenged, on whether it was reasonable and fair. Evidence gathered by the employee's own manager, or by an IT technician who logged in to the machine and browsed around, is open to obvious criticism: files show as accessed after the suspension, dates have changed, and nobody can say exactly what was done. A forensic image taken before anyone examines the computer, by an outside party, with a record of each step, removes that line of attack. The report is addressed to the employer but is written to be read by the employee and, if need be, a tribunal.
Monitoring law in one paragraph, by reference
Examining a worker's computer is processing their personal data. The Information Commissioner's guidance on monitoring workers says employers must have a lawful basis, tell workers what monitoring may take place, and keep it proportionate to the concern, with extra care for special category data and private communications. Acas's guidance on investigations addresses collecting evidence and keeping the process fair. This page does not interpret either. They are short, free and linked below, and an employment adviser will apply them to your facts.
If a claim follows
Employment tribunals regularly decide cases on documents of this kind without expert evidence. The Employment Appeal Tribunal has said that careful thought is needed before any party instructs an expert, and tribunals expect to be consulted. If a tribunal does want expert evidence on a computer issue, that is given by an expert witness and not by this service. The forensic image, if requested within five days of the report, can be passed to that expert. In the great majority of disciplinary matters the report itself, shown to the employee and answered by them, is the end of the technical question.
- Acas, carrying out an investigation (step 3) — www.acas.org.uk/investigations-for-discipline-and-grievance-step-by-step/step-3-carrying-out-an-investigation
- ICO, Data protection and monitoring workers — ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/employment/monitoring-workers/data-protection-and-monitoring-workers/
- De Keyser Ltd v Wilson (EAT, 20 March 2001), case note (expert evidence in employment tribunals) — swarb.co.uk/de-keyser-limited-v-wilson-eat-20-mar-2001/
- Flowers, Mansour and Al-Khateeb, web browser artefacts in private and portable modes (2016) — core.ac.uk/download/196185854.pdf
- ACPO Good Practice Guide for Digital Evidence, Version 5 (the four principles; handling a computer found on or off) — training-on-eppo.era.int/EPPO/kiosk/pdf/ACPO_Good_Practice_Guide.pdf
Each quotation was checked against the source named, on 11 November 2026; where a case was read in a summary or case note, the page says so. Rules are amended from time to time, so use the links for the text in force. This is not legal advice, and none of the bodies named has any connection with this site.
Asked in disputes like this.
Can our IT department do this instead?
They can, but an internal search alters the computer and is easy to criticise. An image taken first by an outside party avoids both problems.
Will the report say the employee did it?
It says what was done under their user account. Who was using the account is for your investigation to decide on all the evidence.
What does it cost?
£800 + VAT for one computer with one drive, paid before the examination starts.
Switched off. Locked away. Then tell us the dispute.
Say what the dispute is about, whose computer it is and whether anything has been started in a court or tribunal. Within a working day you hear whether a factual report is the right tool and whether we can take it on, free of charge. If you go ahead, the fee of £800 + VAT per device is paid on a pro forma invoice before imaging. In the meantime the computer stays off, out of reach and unused.