One computer, one fixed fee: £800 + VATCivil, employment, family, business and private matters · 5–10 working days to the signed reportTalk it through first:0800 6890668
DFEDigital Forensic Expert 0800 6890668 Instruct
BUNDLE PAGE B/10DFE / The dispute / Contract disputes and contested emails

'I never received it' · 'that attachment was different' · sent items · headers · the other end · the provider's logs · native format, not a printout · £800 + VAT

Contract disputes and contested emails. An email is the most quoted and least examined document in commercial litigation. A printout of one is evidence of very little.

Commercial disputes regularly come down to a message: notice said to have been given, an order said to have been confirmed, terms said to have been attached. One party produces a printout; the other says it never arrived, or arrived saying something else. An email exists in several places, on the sender's computer, the sender's mail server, the recipient's server and the recipient's computer, and each holds a slightly different record. A forensic examination of the computer at one end reports what that end holds: the message in its original form with its headers, when it was created and sent, whether it was later edited or deleted. It is often enough to show which account of events the records support.

The drive is imaged firstEvery finding names its recordAn account, not a person£800 + VAT, paid before the work

This page quotes rules, guidance and decided cases and gives the source for each. It is not legal advice; for your own position, ask a solicitor.

Tell us the dispute and whose computer it is; you hear whether a factual report fits before any fee is taken
0800 6890668

What a factual report can give.

A factual report givesWhat one end's computer records about a message: its existence, time, content and any later change
FromThe mail store in the forensic image
It does not giveThe other party's side, or the legal effect of the message

What is alleged, and what the computer may record.

What is allegedWhat the computer may recordWhat it cannot showWorth knowing
'I sent it on the 3rd'Sent item, its headers and timestamps, the attachment as sentDelivery to the recipientServer logs show hand-off
'I never received it'Presence or absence in the mail store, including deleted items; junk folderMessages filtered at the server and never downloadedAbsence on one computer is weak evidence alone
'The attachment was a different version'The attachment stored with the message; its own propertiesWhat the other side openedCompare both ends
'That email has been edited'Inconsistencies between headers, body and store recordsAlteration before it reached this computerSigned headers can sometimes be checked
'It was read'Read status, replies, forwardsThat a person understood itRead flags are easily changed
Webmail only, nothing stored locallyBrowser traces of sessionsMessage contentsRequest a provider export

What to do first, in order.

  1. Keep the message in its original formDo not forward it to your solicitor; forwarding rewrites the headers. Leave it where it is.
  2. Stop using the computer if the dispute is seriousMail clients compact and purge deleted items over time.
  3. Ask your mail provider or IT for server logsMessage tracking logs are often kept for only days or weeks.
  4. Tell your solicitor what the other side saysThe examination can then address the precise disagreement.
  5. Instruct the examinationGive the date, subject line and addresses of the message in question.

Do not

  • Do not rely on a printout or a screenshot of an email.
  • Do not forward the disputed message around.
  • Do not 'tidy' the mailbox.
  • Do not assume a missing email was never sent.
  • Do not expect one end's computer to prove what happened at the other.

In more detail.

What an email carries with it

The internet standard for message format defines header fields that travel with every email: who it is from and to, its date, a unique message identifier, and a trail of 'Received' lines added by each server that handles it. Many messages also carry a cryptographic signature added by the sending domain, under the DKIM standard, which lets a receiving system check that signed parts of the message were not altered in transit. A printout shows none of this. The message as stored in a mail client shows all of it, which is why the original, in place, is what should be examined.

One end of a conversation

A computer can establish what its own mail client holds. If the sender's machine has the message in its sent items with consistent headers and the attachment in question, that is good evidence it was sent in that form. It is not evidence that it was delivered. If the recipient's machine has no trace of it, in the inbox, junk or deleted items, that is some evidence it did not arrive there, subject to server-side filtering and to the many mailboxes that live online and are never fully downloaded. The report states what was found and is explicit about what the other end, or the provider, would need to supply.

Using it in the dispute

Solicitors in contract disputes use a factual email report to test their own client's account before pleading it, and to challenge a document the other side relies on by asking for it in native form. The disclosure rules for electronic documents in England and Wales address native formats and metadata for this reason. If authenticity remains contested at trial, the court may permit expert evidence, which is then given by an expert witness. This service does not interpret the contract, advise on notice provisions or give evidence.

Sources
  1. RFC 5322, Internet Message Format (email header fields) — www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc5322
  2. RFC 6376, DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM) Signatures — www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc6376
  3. Practice Direction 31B (disclosure of electronic documents) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part31/pd_part31b
  4. Practice Direction 57AD (disclosure in the Business and Property Courts) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part-57a-business-and-property-courts/practice-direction-57ad-disclosure-in-the-business-and-property-courts
  5. Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 (experts and assessors) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part35

Each quotation was checked against the source named, on 11 November 2026; where a case was read in a summary or case note, the page says so. Rules are amended from time to time, so use the links for the text in force. This is not legal advice, and none of the bodies named has any connection with this site.

Asked in disputes like this.

Can you prove the other side received my email?

Not from your computer alone. The report shows what was sent from your end; delivery is shown by server logs or the recipient's records.

Can you tell if an email was altered?

The report sets out any inconsistencies in the stored message and its headers. Whether that shows alteration is a conclusion for others.

What does it cost?

£800 + VAT for one computer with one drive, paid before the examination starts.

Switched off. Locked away. Then tell us the dispute.

Say what the dispute is about, whose computer it is and whether anything has been started in a court or tribunal. Within a working day you hear whether a factual report is the right tool and whether we can take it on, free of charge. If you go ahead, the fee of £800 + VAT per device is paid on a pro forma invoice before imaging. In the meantime the computer stays off, out of reach and unused.