Experts' discussion · agreed and disagreed · joint statement · concurrent evidence at trial · the image both experts examine · not for settling the case
Joint statements and concurrent evidence. Two digital forensic experts given the same image will agree on most of it. The court's procedures are designed to find the remainder.
Once each side has an expert and reports are exchanged, the court's interest is in shrinking the dispute. The rules let it direct the experts to discuss the issues and to prepare a statement of what they agree, what they disagree on, and why. At trial it may hear them at the same time, a procedure usually called hot-tubbing. In digital cases these steps are often very effective, because the raw material, the image of a drive, is identical for both experts and many findings are simply reproducible. This page describes the procedure for parties who are heading into it, which will be with expert witnesses instructed elsewhere.
This page quotes rules, guidance and decided cases and gives the source for each. It is not legal advice; for your own position, ask a solicitor.
Tell us the dispute and whose computer it is; you hear whether a factual report fits before any fee is taken
0800 6890668
The court may, at any stage, direct a discussion between experts
What the rule requires.
Term by term.
| Rule or term | What it says | Where it applies | What it means for a factual report |
|---|---|---|---|
| Experts' discussion | The court may direct one 'at any stage' | CPR 35.12(1) | The image and report from a factual examination can be common ground |
| Specified issues | The court may specify what is to be discussed | CPR 35.12(2) | Facts already established narrow the list |
| Joint statement | A statement of issues agreed and not agreed, with reasons for disagreement | CPR 35.12(3) | Not something a factual examiner signs |
| Purpose | 'not for experts to settle cases but to agree and narrow issues' | PD 35, paragraph 9.2 | Settlement remains for the parties |
| Concurrent evidence | The court may direct that experts from like disciplines give evidence concurrently | PD 35, paragraph 11.1 | No attendance by this service |
| The judge leads | 'the judge will initiate the discussion by asking the experts, in turn, for their views' | PD 35, paragraph 11.4 | A description of trial procedure only |
Points to note.
Worth keeping in mind
- What experts agree on. In computer cases the experts usually agree the mechanics: that the image is a true copy, that a device with a given serial number was connected at given times, that a file was created on a given date. They differ on inference: whether a pattern of deletions is consistent with routine housekeeping, or whether clock anomalies indicate tampering.
- Lawyers stay out. Guidance from the Civil Justice Council addresses the conduct of experts' discussions, including that the experts' statement should be their own. Parties should not expect to dictate what their expert agrees. This follows from the expert's duty to the court.
- The value of one image. Disputes about method fall away when both experts examine the same verified image. Where a factual examination was done early and its image preserved, it can be supplied to both sides' experts, with its hash values, on the instructing party's request within five days of the report.
In more detail.
The discussion and the statement
Rule 35.12 gives the court power to direct a discussion between experts to identify and discuss the expert issues and, where possible, reach an agreed opinion. It may specify the issues, and may direct that after the discussion the experts prepare a statement for the court of the issues on which they agree and those on which they disagree, with a summary of their reasons for disagreeing. Practice Direction 35 says the purpose 'is not for experts to settle cases but to agree and narrow issues'. In practice the joint statement becomes the working document at trial.
Concurrent evidence
The practice direction also provides that at any stage the court may direct that some or all of the evidence of experts from like disciplines be given concurrently. The experts sit together. The judge begins by asking each in turn for their view on an issue, invites each to comment on the other's, and then counsel ask questions. In technical disputes this tends to expose quickly where the real difference lies, because an expert must respond directly to a peer and not only to a cross-examining barrister.
What it means for a party now
If your dispute is likely to reach this stage, three practical points follow. Preserve the evidence early so that both experts work from the same thing. Choose an expert who can explain their reasoning to another expert as well as to a judge. And budget for the joint process: discussions, drafting the statement and attendance are charged for. None of that is this service's work. Its contribution, where it is used, is upstream: the early image and a factual account that both sides' experts can check for themselves.
- Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 (experts and assessors) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part35
- Practice Direction 35 (form and content of an expert's report; statement of truth) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part35/pd_part35
- Civil Justice Council, Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims (2014) — www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/experts-guidance-cjc-aug-2014-amended-dec-8.pdf
- SWGDE Best Practices for Computer Forensic Acquisitions v2.0 (image types, hashing, records to keep) — www.swgde.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/2023-06-15-SWGDE-Best-Practices-for-Computer-Forensic-Acquisitions-17-F-002-2.0.pdf
- Crypto Open Patent Alliance v Wright [2024] EWHC 1198 (Ch), judgment appendix (forged documents) — www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/COPAv-Wright-Judgment-Appendix.pdf
Each quotation was checked against the source named, on 11 November 2026; where a case was read in a summary or case note, the page says so. Rules are amended from time to time, so use the links for the text in force. This is not legal advice, and none of the bodies named has any connection with this site.
Asked about this rule.
Will your forensic engineer meet the other side's expert?
No. The engineer does not act as an expert witness.
Can both experts use the image you made?
Yes, if the instructing party asks for a copy within five days of the report and chooses to share it.
Is a joint statement binding?
Its effect is governed by the rules and is a question for your solicitor.
Switched off. Locked away. Then tell us the dispute.
Say what the dispute is about, whose computer it is and whether anything has been started in a court or tribunal. Within a working day you hear whether a factual report is the right tool and whether we can take it on, free of charge. If you go ahead, the fee of £800 + VAT per device is paid on a pro forma invoice before imaging. In the meantime the computer stays off, out of reach and unused.