Duty to the court · overrides the duty to the paying party · independent, objective, unbiased · must say when the view changes · not an advocate
The expert's duty to the court. You pay the expert. The expert does not work for you. That is the first thing to understand before instructing one.
Clients are often surprised by how little an expert witness is on their side. The rules are explicit. An expert's duty is to help the court, and that duty overrides any obligation to whoever instructs or pays. The practice direction says expert evidence should be 'the independent product of the expert uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation', and that experts should give 'objective, unbiased opinions'. An expert who finds material that harms the instructing party must say so, and one whose opinion changes must tell everyone. This page sets those duties out. They bind expert witnesses. They are also the reason a factual examination, which gives no opinion, is a different and simpler thing.
This page quotes rules, guidance and decided cases and gives the source for each. It is not legal advice; for your own position, ask a solicitor.
Tell us the dispute and whose computer it is; you hear whether a factual report fits before any fee is taken
0800 6890668
It is the duty of experts to help the court on matters within their expertise.
What the rule requires.
Term by term.
| Rule or term | What it says | Where it applies | What it means for a factual report |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overriding duty | The duty to the court overrides any obligation to the instructing or paying party | Civil proceedings, England and Wales | Not an expert's report; but the instruction is recorded and findings are not selected to suit |
| Independence | Evidence should be 'the independent product of the expert uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation' | PD 35, paragraph 2.1 | The fee here is fixed and paid in advance, whatever is found |
| Objectivity | Experts 'should assist the court by providing objective, unbiased opinions on matters within their expertise' | PD 35, paragraph 2.2 | No opinions are given |
| Not an advocate | Experts should not assume the role of an advocate | PD 35, paragraph 2.2 | The report does not argue a case |
| Change of view | 'such change of view should be communicated to all the parties without delay' | PD 35, paragraph 2.5 | Not applicable to a factual report; errors found would be corrected |
| Family and other courts | Equivalent duties in their own rules | FPR Part 25; Northern Ireland practice direction | See the pages on each |
Points to note.
Worth keeping in mind
- Why the duty exists. Expert evidence is opinion, which courts ordinarily exclude. It is let in because the court needs help with matters outside its own knowledge. The price of admission is that the expert serves the court's need and not the party's cause. Guidance from the Civil Justice Council tells experts to consider whether the opinion would be the same if given on the instructions of the other side.
- What it means when you instruct one. You may receive a report you do not like. You cannot have it rewritten to order: solicitors may ask for clarity and relevance, but must not ask an expert to change an opinion. Instructions given to the expert must be summarised in the report. Budget, and decide strategy, on the footing that the expert will say what they think.
- A factual report by comparison. A factual forensic report is not opinion evidence and its author owes no duty under Part 35. It should nevertheless be written as if both sides will read it, because they usually do. The reports produced here record the instructions, state findings with their sources whichever way they point, and list what could not be determined.
In more detail.
The rule and the practice direction
Part 35 opens by restricting expert evidence to what is reasonably required. It then states the duty: to help the court on matters within the expert's expertise, overriding obligations to those instructing or paying. Practice Direction 35 fills in what that means in conduct. Expert evidence is to be the expert's independent product. Opinions are to be objective and unbiased. The expert should make clear when a question falls outside their expertise and when a conclusion is provisional. If, after exchange of reports, the expert changes their view on a material matter, that is to be communicated to all parties without delay.
How it shows in a digital case
In computer cases the duty bites in practical ways. An expert instructed by an employer who finds that the 'stolen' files were also emailed to the employee by her manager must report it. An expert who cannot tell whether a clock change was deliberate must say that it is consistent with both. An expert asked about phones when their experience is in computers must say so. Each of these weakens the instructing party's case, and each is required. Reports that omit such matters are the ones that come apart in cross-examination, to the cost of the party who commissioned them.
Why this service stays on the factual side
A fixed fee, no court attendance and no opinion are connected choices. Once an examiner gives opinions for use in proceedings, the rules apply: permission, a compliant report, written questions, discussions with the other side's expert, and attendance at trial, all of unknown duration. This service does not take that on. It reports what the computer records. A party who needs someone to help the court interpret those records instructs an expert witness, who will then owe the duties described here to the court and not to the party.
- Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 (experts and assessors) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part35
- Practice Direction 35 (form and content of an expert's report; statement of truth) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part35/pd_part35
- Civil Justice Council, Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims (2014) — www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/experts-guidance-cjc-aug-2014-amended-dec-8.pdf
- Crown Prosecution Service, Expert Evidence legal guidance — www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/expert-evidence
- Elcomsoft, why digital forensic reports don't survive cross-examination (July 2026) — blog.elcomsoft.com/2026/07/why-digital-forensic-reports-dont-survive-cross-examination/
Each quotation was checked against the source named, on 11 November 2026; where a case was read in a summary or case note, the page says so. Rules are amended from time to time, so use the links for the text in force. This is not legal advice, and none of the bodies named has any connection with this site.
Asked about this rule.
If I pay the expert, do they work for me?
No. Under the rules their duty to the court overrides any obligation to the party instructing or paying them.
Can I ask an expert to leave something out?
The guidance for experts and solicitors says experts must not be asked to alter their opinions. Ask your solicitor how instructions and drafts are properly handled.
Does your forensic engineer owe this duty?
No, because the engineer does not give expert evidence. The report is factual.
Switched off. Locked away. Then tell us the dispute.
Say what the dispute is about, whose computer it is and whether anything has been started in a court or tribunal. Within a working day you hear whether a factual report is the right tool and whether we can take it on, free of charge. If you go ahead, the fee of £800 + VAT per device is paid on a pro forma invoice before imaging. In the meantime the computer stays off, out of reach and unused.