One computer, one fixed fee: £800 + VATCivil, employment, family, business and private matters · 5–10 working days to the signed reportTalk it through first:0800 6890668
DFEDigital Forensic Expert 0800 6890668 Instruct
BUNDLE PAGE D/08DFE / Choosing one / Challenging the other side's forensic report

Served with a report · read it against a checklist · continuity · image · sources · time zones · account or person · what is missing · your own computer · £800 + VAT

Challenging the other side's forensic report. Most weak forensic reports fail on things a careful lawyer can see without a second expert: what was examined, how, and what the findings really say.

A forensic report from the other side arrives looking authoritative. It has hash values, screenshots of software and confident conclusions. Before deciding it must be answered by an expert of your own, read it against the checklist on this page. A surprising number of reports do not say how the computer was handled before imaging, cite no source for key findings, give times without zones, or move from 'the account' to 'the defendant' without comment. Those are points a solicitor can raise in correspondence or by request for further information. Where the dispute is one of technical opinion, you will need an expert witness, and this service is not one.

The drive is imaged firstEvery finding names its recordAn account, not a person£800 + VAT, paid before the work

Tell us the dispute and whose computer it is; you hear whether a factual report fits before any fee is taken
0800 6890668

What to look for.

Look forSpecific gaps in the other side's report that can be put in writing
Check byThe report itself, read against published minimum contents
Be wary ofA general attack on the examiner's competence without particulars

Point by point, with this service's answer.

What to checkWhy it mattersWhat a good answer looks likeThis service
Was the computer used between the events and imaging?Later use alters records and overwrites deleted dataContinuity from the date of the eventsAsk for the handling record
Was it imaged, and are hashes given?Without an image nobody can verify anythingAcquisition details and hash valuesAsk for a copy of the image
Does each finding cite a record?Unsourced findings cannot be testedPaths and record namesAsk for the source of each key finding
Are time zones stated?UTC and local time differ; summer time shifts an hourA zone for every timeAsk which zone, and how the clock was checked
Account or person?A login is not an identityCareful wordingAsk on what basis a person is named
What was not examined?Selective examination can misleadA limitations sectionAsk what was excluded and why
Is it fact or opinion?Opinion needs permission and a qualified witnessClear separationTake a view on whether Part 35 is engaged

Five questions to ask, and the answers you get here.

QUESTION 1May we have a copy of the forensic image?

It lets your own examiner or expert verify the findings.

This service

Not applicable to our reports' recipients: our image is offered to the instructing party for five days.

QUESTION 2What is the source of the finding at paragraph X?

The answer is either a record or an assumption.

This service

This service does not review other providers' reports.

QUESTION 3Who handled the computer before it reached the examiner?

Gaps in continuity are common and important.

This service

Our reports record handling from receipt.

QUESTION 4Is the author giving expert evidence, and has permission been given?

If not, opinions in the report may be objectionable.

This service

Our reports contain no opinion evidence.

QUESTION 5Can our own client's computer be examined?

Often the best answer to a report is the facts from your side.

This service

Yes, with your client's authority: £800 + VAT.

In more detail.

Why reports fail

A forensic software company's article on why digital forensic reports do not survive cross-examination lists familiar causes: over-reliance on tool output, findings stated without understanding of the underlying artefact, gaps in the chain of custody, and conclusions that go beyond the data. None of those needs a competing expert to spot. They show up as missing sections and unsupported sentences. A solicitor who writes asking for the handling record, the image, the source of three named findings and the time zone used will often learn more from the reply, or the lack of one, than from commissioning a rebuttal.

What you can ask for

In civil proceedings in England and Wales, where the other side relies on an expert's report, the rules allow written questions to be put to the expert for clarification, and require the report to state the substance of the instructions. The disclosure rules for electronic documents address native-format copies. Whether the document served is an expert's report at all, and what procedural steps are open to you, are for you as the lawyer. From a technical standpoint the key request is always the same: a copy of the image, with its hash values, so that the findings can be checked independently.

Where this service fits, and where it does not

This service does not critique other examiners' reports, advise on cross-examination or provide an expert to answer one. Those are an expert witness's functions. What it can do is examine a computer your own client controls and report the facts from that side: for example, that the email said to have been received was never in the mailbox, or that the client's laptop shows no connection of the drive alleged. Sometimes that answers the other side's report more directly than any critique. If, after that, opinion is still in dispute, the image can go to the expert you instruct.

Sources
  1. Elcomsoft, why digital forensic reports don't survive cross-examination (July 2026) — blog.elcomsoft.com/2026/07/why-digital-forensic-reports-dont-survive-cross-examination/
  2. Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 (experts and assessors) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part35
  3. Practice Direction 31B (disclosure of electronic documents) — www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part31/pd_part31b
  4. SWGDE Requirements for Report Writing in Digital and Multimedia Forensics v1.0 (minimum report elements) — www.swgde.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/2018-11-20-SWGDE-Requirements-for-Report-Writin.pdf
  5. ACPO Good Practice Guide for Digital Evidence, Version 5 (the four principles; handling a computer found on or off) — training-on-eppo.era.int/EPPO/kiosk/pdf/ACPO_Good_Practice_Guide.pdf
  6. Forensic Focus / Belkasoft, the 'I've been hacked' defence (attribution) — www.forensicfocus.com/articles/the-ive-been-hacked-defence/

Each quotation was checked against the source named, on 11 November 2026; where a case was read in a summary or case note, the page says so. Rules are amended from time to time, so use the links for the text in force. This is not legal advice, and none of the bodies named has any connection with this site.

Asked when choosing.

Can you review the other side's forensic report for us?

No. Reviewing and answering a report is an expert witness's work.

Can you examine our own client's computer in response?

Yes, with their authority, for a factual report: £800 + VAT for one computer with one drive.

How do we get the other side's image?

By asking, and failing that by the procedural routes your rules provide. That is a matter for the solicitor with conduct.

Switched off. Locked away. Then tell us the dispute.

Say what the dispute is about, whose computer it is and whether anything has been started in a court or tribunal. Within a working day you hear whether a factual report is the right tool and whether we can take it on, free of charge. If you go ahead, the fee of £800 + VAT per device is paid on a pro forma invoice before imaging. In the meantime the computer stays off, out of reach and unused.